There’s been a leak at England’s Secret Intelligence Service (SIS) and George Woodhouse (Michael Fassbender) has one week to find out who the mole is. Black Bag begins conventionally enough, with two men meeting and exchanging cryptic info, but quickly distances itself from the more familiar tropes of the espionage thriller, subverting certain expectations and embracing others, as a clear love letter to the genre. We move to an awkward dinner scene straight out of Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf with two other couples who work together at the agency.
Clarissa (Marisa Abela) and Freddie (Tom Burke) are in a whirlwind of a relationship, rife with infidelity and distrust. The two probably don’t even like each other, but in this line of work, it’s impossible to have a relationship with anyone outside of the life. Then there’s Dr. Vaughn (Naomie Harris), the departmental psychiatrist and James (Regé-Jean Page), a young agent who’s meteorically rising through the ranks.
After the awkward, contentious, drunken dinner party, we follow each couple, and each individual of the couple, as a means of exploring the dangerous, lonely life of a spy. Whoever the mole is could be anybody, even Woodhouse’s wife Kathryn (Cate Blanchett) who, when asked if she’d ever lie to him, she smugly answers, “Only if I have to.” When she asks if he’d ever kill for her, he answers the same, as we cut to Woodhouse’s superior, who dies of a poisoning, disguised to look like a heart attack.
The audience is thrown for a loop again and again, with red herring after red herring having us question everyone’s motives. The plot itself is kept intentionally vague. There are Russian operatives, there is a plan for a nuclear meltdown that will kill thousands, but it’s all in the background. This isn’t a James Bond flick (even though former Bond actor Pierce Brosnan is in it), so we rarely see the results of their duplicitous work and double-crosses. What we witness are the people who pull the strings behind the action. It’s a tale of intrigue about the puppet masters themselves.
Black Bag, at its best, is a witty, exciting thriller that manages to propel a story through dialogue instead of nonstop action, brilliantly performed by a cast of talented actors. Even though Koepp’s dialogue and Soderbergh’s direction are as good as ever, the film didn’t totally work for me. Far too frequently, the plot itself feels too manufactured and contrived, existing merely as an excuse for this movie to exist in the first place. Story and character motivations feel secondary to a film that takes pride in how clever it can be with misdirection. It’s charming, and it’s refreshing to see a movie made for grown-up audiences, but it feels a bit half-baked when all is said and done.
VIDEO
Steven Soderbergh acted as his own cinematographer under the pseudonym Peter Andrews and his lighting evokes the look and feel of a lot of similar spy-thrillers. I loved the overlit, bloomy looks of light sources, particularly in the dinner sequence early on in the film, which reminded me Janusz Kaminski’s cinematography in Munich. Black Bag, though a contemporary story, evokes a 1960s aesthetic through costuming and set design—but the end result is closer to noir than James Bond. It’s a sleek look, nuanced and hidden in the shadows, instead of bright and boisterous. Details throughout are sharp and detailed and the contrast between light and dark in those complexly layered shots is wonderfully realized.
SOUND
Black Bag comes equipped with a 5.1 surround mix, encoded in Dolby TrueHD. Right from the get-go, you know you’re in for a stellar mix, as a single Steadicam shot follows Michael Fassbender from a city street, to the inside of a bustling dance club, and back outside again. The entirety of the soundstage envelops the listener throughout, from subtle atmospheric noise, thumping club music, and then having that music as a distant memory playing quietly through the satellite speakers. The entire film is mixed well, with dialogue clarity favored throughout. There’s not a ton of action in the film, but David Holmes’ jazzy, bassy score gets the most play throughout the rear of the sound stage, as well as frequent atmospheric effects depending on the setting of the scene.
EXTRAS
There are not too many supplemental features to be found here, sadly, outside of some deleted scenes and a pair of featurettes. One featurette is focused on the talent in front of the camera, highlighting its performances, and the other behind the camera, highlighting the film’s aesthetic.
Deleted Scenes (HD 6:25)
The Company of Talent (HD 10:12)
Designing Black Bag (HD 5:25)
CONCLUSION
Black Bag is a fun movie that revels in its own creativity. It understands the complexities of Spy vs. Spy films and uses every storytelling technique it has up its sleeve to direct, misdirect, and subvert our expectations. And while I admire the craft – acting, directing, writing all aces – it feels a bit empty at the end of the day, as it’s more interested in being a result of creativity than in being an actual story with something interesting to say about these games of intrigue. As a product, though, with fantastic A/V stats, it’s hard to argue that it looks and sounds great. Black Bag is Recommended by me only to fans of the genre or fans of Soderbergh.
FILM ⭐️⭐️⭐️
PICTURE ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
SOUND ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
EXTRAS ⭐️⭐️